| Will | Hayes | 2025 | New Canaan | Denver | Big East | I |
| Tucker | Hess | 2025 | Rye | Villanova | Big East | I |
| Bryce | Lyden | 2025 | New Canaan | Michigan | Big 10 | I |
| Josh | Marcus | 2025 | Staples | UNC | ACC | I |
| Brendan | Mullahy | 2025 | Taft | Notre Dame | ACC | I |
| Lukas | Hublitz | 2024 | Brunswick | Virginia | ACC | I |
| Kaleb | Griffith | 2024 | Loomis Chaffee | Richmond | A10 | I |
| Matthew | Jeffery | 2024 | Cheshire | Notre Dame | ACC | I |
| Brady | Pokorny | 2024 | Darien | Notre Dame | ACC | I |
| Dillon | Stephens | 2024 | New Canaan | Syracuse | ACC | I |
| Parker | Hoffman | 2024 | Boys Latin | UNC | ACC | I |
| Kyle | Colsey | 2024 | Ridgefield | Virginia | ACC | I |
| Becket | Burley | 2024 | New Canaan | Franklin & Marshall | Centennial | III |
| Cisco | Celotto | 2024 | Staples | Gettysburg | Centennial | III |
| Colin | Finnigan | 2024 | New Canaan | Rhodes College | SAA | III |
| Briggs | McGuckin | 2024 | Darien | Bowdoin | NESCAC | III |
| Ryan | Roberts | 2024 | Canterbury | Union | NESCAC | III |
| Hayden | Roeder | 2024 | New Canaan | Franklin & Marshall | Centennial | III |
| Morgan | Ruppenstein | 2024 | Darien | Bates | NESCAC | III |
| Jack | Sconziano | 2024 | New Canaan | Skidmore | Liberty | III |
| Gavin | McCarthy | 2024 | Fairfield Prep | Bryant | America East | I |
| John | Kleinbeck | 2024 | Fairfield Ludlowe | Air Force | ASUN | I |
| Conner | Flanagan | 2024 | Wilton | Utah | ASUN | I |
| Doster | Crowell | 2024 | New Canaan | Michigan | Big Ten | I |
| Hudson | Hausmann | 2024 | Brunswick | Brown | Ivy | I |
| Jack | Balzi | 2024 | New Milford | Sacred Heart Univ. | MAAC | I |
| Dom | Basti | 2024 | Notre Dame West Haven | Sacred Heart Univ. | MAAC | I |
| Cooper | Callahan | 2024 | Fairfield Prep | Sacred Heart Univ. | MAAC | I |
| Timmy | Shannehan | 2024 | Fairfield Prep | Boston University | Patriot | I |
| Carter | Hagen | 2024 | Darien | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| Charles | Kurtz | 2023 | Cheshire | UMASS | A10 | I |
| Will | Erdmann | 2023 | Brunswick | Virginia | ACC | I |
| Grafton | Ely | 2023 | Darien | Mercer | ASUN | I |
| Will | Coale | 2023 | Brunswick | Georgetown | Big East | I |
| Leo | Sequenzia | 2023 | Staples | Providence | Big East | I |
| Ellis | McDonald | 2023 | Avon Old Farms | Ohio State | Big Ten | I |
| Ryan | Connelly | 2023 | New Canaan | Franklin & Marshall | Centennial | III |
| Marco | Firmender | 2023 | Fairfield Prep | UPENN | Ivy | I |
| Teddy | Rosen | 2023 | New Canaan | Bates | NESCAC | III |
| Cameron | Wietfeldt | 2023 | New Canaan | Bowdoin | NESCAC | III |
| Tyler | Clark | 2023 | Staples | Army | Patriot | I |
| Tyler | Fox | 2023 | Fairfield Prep | Boston University | Patriot | I |
| Peter | Grandolfo | 2023 | Fairfield Prep | Bucknell | Patriot | I |
| Mac | McGahren | 2023 | Darien | Bucknell | Patriot | I |
| Matthew | Shepard | 2023 | Ridgefield | Bucknell | Patriot | I |
| Nick | Lancaster | 2023 | Taft | Colgate | Patriot | I |
| Gavin | Ouhrabka | 2023 | New Hampton | Holy Cross | Patriot | I |
| Christopher | Reinhardt | 2023 | Ridgefield | Lafayette | Patriot | I |
| Luke | Winkler | 2023 | Ridgefield | Lehigh | Patriot | I |
| Jake | Wilson | 2023 | Darien | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| Thomas | Ricciardelli | 2022 | Taft | Notre Dame | ACC | I |
| Ryan | Plunkett | 2023 | Darien | Catholic University | Landmark | III |
| Ryan | Colsey | 2022 | Ridgefield | Virginia | ACC | I |
| Henry | Dodge | 2022 | Staples | Vermont | America East | I |
| Hayden | Fruhling | 2022 | Hill School | Vermont | America East | I |
| Jeremiah | Stafford | 2022 | Darien | Air Force | ASUN | I |
| Joe | Cesare | 2022 | Darien | Georgetown | Big East | I |
| David | Evanchick | 2022 | Darien | Villanova | Big East | I |
| Mason | Whitney | 2022 | Fairfield Prep | Michigan | Big Ten | I |
| Ben | Spinelli | 2022 | Taft | Penn State | Big Ten | I |
| Sam | Tomack | 2022 | Avon Old Farms | Drexel | CAA | I |
| Carter | Connors | 2022 | New Canaan | Franklin & Marshall | Centennial | III |
| Finn | Pokorny | 2022 | Darien | Harvard | Ivy | I |
| Cooper | Carr | 2022 | Fairfield Ludlowe | RPI | Liberty | III |
| Sean | Wiseman | 2022 | Wilton | St. Lawrence | Liberty | III |
| Finn | Hoey | 2022 | Fairfield Ludlowe | Sacred Heart Univ. | MAAC | I |
| Liam | Keesser | 2022 | Fairfield Ludlowe | Scared Heart Univ. | MAAC | I |
| Matthew | Sheinberg | 2022 | Taft | Amherst | NESCAC | III |
| Alex | Byrne | 2022 | Berkshire | Bowdoin | NESCAC | III |
| Michael | Norton | 2022 | New Canaan | Bowdoin | NESCAC | III |
| Will | Heisler | 2022 | Staples | Colby | NESCAC | III |
| Jack | Almeida | 2022 | St. George’s | Trinity | NESCAC | III |
| CJ | Lauretani | 2022 | Ridgefield | Lafayette | Patriot | I |
| Matthew | Minicus | 2022 | Darien | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| Christian | Alliegro | 2022 | Darien | Navy | Patriot | I |
| Will | Punkett | 2021 | Darien | Hobart | A10 | I |
| Kevin | Lynch | 2021 | Staples | UMASS | A10 | I |
| Luke | Waters | 2021 | Brunswick | Duke | ACC | I |
| Jeffrey | Ricciardelli | 2021 | Taft | Notre Dame | ACC | I |
| Lucas | Delgado | 2021 | Brunswick | Michigan | Big Ten | I |
| Mike | Frechette | 2021 | Berkshire | Michigan | Big Ten | I |
| Cornelius | Vanwees | 2021 | Ridgefield | Michigan | Big Ten | I |
| Andy | Demopoulos | 2021 | Darien | Brown | Ivy | I |
| Sean | Fox | 2021 | Taft | Cornell | Ivy | I |
| Elijah | Cohen | 2021 | Taft | Harvard | Ivy | I |
| Chris | Canet | 2021 | New Canaan | UPENN | Ivy | I |
| Leo | Johnson | 2021 | Avon Old Farms | Yale | Ivy | I |
| Nate | Stevens | 2021 | Westminster | St. Lawrence | Liberty | III |
| Andrew | Amirsakis | 2021 | Darien | Vassar | Liberty | III |
| Christain | Wolter | 2021 | New Canaan | Ohio Wesleyan | NCAC | III |
| Hayden | Shin | 2021 | New Canaan | Trinity | NESCAC | III |
| Callum | Wood | 2021 | New Canaan | Tufts | NESCAC | III |
| Harry | Appelt | 2021 | New Canaan | Williams | NESCAC | III |
| Blake | Burchill | 2021 | Brunswick | Bucknell | Patriot | I |
| Ryan | Caione | 2021 | New Canaan | Bucknell | Patriot | I |
| Jack | Scoma | 2021 | Lawrenceville | Lehigh | Patriot | I |
| Michael | Callahan | 2021 | Avon Old Farms | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| Patrick | Yowan | 2021 | Choate | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| Will | Cosco | 2021 | New Canaan | Rhodes College | SAA | III |
| Bradley | Rider | 2020 | Salisbury | Highpoint | A10 | I |
| Robbie | Lionetti | 2020 | Branford /Avon Old Farms (PG) | Air Force | ASUN | I |
| Jack | Finnigan | 2020 | New Canaan | Utah | ASUN | I |
| Jack | Whitney | 2020 | Berkshire | Michigan | Big Ten | I |
| Justin | Wietfeldt | 2020 | New Canaan | Michigan | Big Ten | I |
| Cole | Sprinkle | 2020 | Choate | Drexel | CAA | I |
| Luke | Tomack | 2020 | Choate | Drexel | CAA | I |
| Jake | Goralnik | 2020 | Salisbury | Franklin & Marshall | Centennial | III |
| Andrew | Symon | 2020 | New Canaan | Swarthmore | Centennial | III |
| Isaac | Sacks | 2020 | Brunswick | Brown | Ivy | I |
| Mikey | Mauricio | 2020 | Brunswick | Dartmouth | Ivy | I |
| Liam | Griffiths | 2020 | New Canaan / Deerfield (PG) | Harvard | Ivy | I |
| Carter | Flanagan | 2020 | Darien | St. Lawrence | Liberty | III |
| Charlie | Coale | 2020 | Brien McMahon | Stevenson | MAC Commonwealth | III |
| Patrick | Murdock | 2020 | Berkshire | Bowdoin | NESCAC | III |
| Will | Nelson | 2020 | Darien | Trinity | NESCAC | III |
| Sam | Cragin | 2020 | Darien | Williams | NESCAC | III |
| Kyle | Atherton | 2020 | Trumbull | Army | Patriot | I |
| Bennett | Ong | 2020 | New Canaan | Army | Patriot | I |
| Patrick | Ciquera | 2020 | Staples | Bucknell | Patriot | I |
| Henry | Quaintance | 2020 | Berkshire | Bucknell | Patriot | I |
| Michael | Minicus | 2020 | Darien | Colgate | Patriot | I |
| Wyatt | Pastor | 2020 | Westminster | Lafayette | Patriot | I |
| Jackson | Peters | 2020 | Darien | Navy | Patriot | I |
| AJ | Delgado | 2019 | Brunswick | Duke | ACC | I |
| Quintin | O'Connell | 2019 | New Canaan | UNC | ACC | I |
| Tim | Norton | 2019 | New Canaan | Vermont | America East | I |
| Mason | Reale | 2019 | Fairfield Prep | Villanova | Big East | I |
| Eddie | Glassmeyer | 2019 | Brunswick | Johns Hopkins | Big Ten | I |
| George | Dumbauld | 2019 | New Canaan | Drexel | CAA | I |
| Donny | Macaluso | 2019 | Staples | Fairfield University | CAA | I |
| Jack | Murdock | 2019 | Westminster | Colorado College | HCAC | III |
| Christian | Barnard | 2019 | Brunswick | Harvard | Ivy | I |
| Blake | Cellar | 2019 | Darien | UPENN | Ivy | I |
| Andrew | Tinnesz | 2019 | Trumbull HS | Ithaca | Liberty | III |
| Matt | Cosco | 2019 | New Canaan | Furman | N/A | I |
| Charlie | Walsh | 2019 | Darien | Denison | NCAC | III |
| Carl | Mazabras | 2019 | New Canaan | Ohio Wesleyan | NCAC | III |
| Charles | Packard | 2019 | Brunswick | Amherst | NESCAC | III |
| Zach | Liston | 2019 | Greens Farms Academy | Colby | NESCAC | III |
| Finn | O'Connor | 2019 | Fairfield Prep | Middlebury | NESCAC | III |
| Walker | Stevens | 2019 | Westminster | Middlebury | NESCAC | III |
| Tommy | Swank | 2019 | Daniel Hand | Tufts | NESCAC | III |
| Robert | Gallop | 2019 | Berkshire | Boston University | Patriot | I |
| Walker | Ker | 2019 | New Canaan | Boston University | Patriot | I |
| Beaudan | Szuluk | 2019 | Avon Old Farms | Lafayette | Patriot | I |
| Hudson | Pokorny | 2019 | Darien | Washington & Lee | ODAC | III |
| Xander | Dickson | 2018 | Brunswick | Virginia | ACC | I |
| Logan | McGovern | 2018 | Darien | Bryant | America East | I |
| Andrew | Darby | 2018 | Darien | Michigan | Big Ten | I |
| Will | Kirshner | 2018 | Harrison (NY) | Fairfield University | CAA | I |
| Peter | O'Sullivan | 2018 | Avon Old Farms | Dickinson | Centennial | III |
| Brennan | Troy | 2018 | Brunswick | Colorado College | HCAC | III |
| Darian | Cook | 2018 | Avon Old Farms | Brown | Ivy | I |
| Chase | Strupp | 2018 | New Canaan | Harvard | Ivy | I |
| Patrick | Burkinshaw | 2018 | Brunswick | UPENN | Ivy | I |
| Jack | Joyce | 2018 | Darien | UPENN | Ivy | I |
| Jack | Ocken | 2018 | Brunswick | Yale | Ivy | I |
| Joe | Scarfi | 2018 | Wilton | St. Lawrence | Liberty | III |
| John | Sheehan | 2018 | Taft | Middlebury | NESCAC | III |
| Mac | Deane | 2018 | New Canaan | Trinity | NESCAC | III |
| Charlie | Olsen | 2018 | Darien | Trinity | NESCAC | III |
| Joe | Murtha | 2018 | Wilton | Tufts | NESCAC | III |
| Blake | Sommi | 2018 | Darien | Tufts | NESCAC | III |
| Owen | Shin | 2018 | New Canaan | Wesleyan | NESCAC | III |
| Nick | Crovatto | 2018 | New Canaan | Bucknell | Patriot | I |
| Brian | Minicus | 2018 | Darien | Colgate | Patriot | I |
| Sean | Morris | 2017 | Brunswick | UNC | ACC | I |
| Ryan | O’Connell | 2017 | New Canaan | UNC | ACC | I |
| Jackson | Appelt | 2017 | New Canaan | Virginia | ACC | I |
| John | Fox | 2017 | Brunswick | Virginia | ACC | I |
| Andrew | Bauersfeld | 2017 | New Canaan | Vermont | America East | I |
| Ethan | Burger | 2017 | Staples | Vermont | America East | I |
| Spencer | Decker | 2017 | Brunswick | Vermont | America East | I |
| Tommy | O'Dea | 2017 | New Canaan | Utah | ASUN | I |
| Drew | Morris | 2017 | New Canaan | Maryland | Big Ten | I |
| Alex | Buckanavage | 2017 | Brunswick | Michigan | Big Ten | I |
| James | Loughran | 2017 | Fairfield Prep | Endicott | CCC | III |
| Jimmy | Heidt | 2017 | Brunswick | Dartmouth | Ivy | I |
| Kyle | Salvatore | 2017 | Taft | Harvard | Ivy | I |
| Chris | Brown | 2017 | Fairfield Prep | Princeton | Ivy | I |
| Max | Metalios | 2017 | Brunswick | UPENN | Ivy | I |
| Graham | Braden | 2017 | New Canaan | Denison | NCAC | III |
| James | Freyre | 2017 | New Canaan | Denison | NCAC | III |
| James | Crovatto | 2017 | New Canaan | Amherst | NESCAC | III |
| Jack | Hoelzer | 2017 | New Canaan | Middlebury | NESCAC | III |
| Benjamin | Shapiro | 2017 | Brunswick | Wesleyan | NESCAC | III |
| Jake | Bieler | 2017 | Darien | Army | Patriot | I |
| Kevin | Lindley | 2017 | Darien | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| Corey | Millhouse | 2017 | Hamden Hall | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| Sam | Shafer | 2017 | Trinity-Pawling | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| Michael | Reale | 2016 | Staples | Richmond | A10 | I |
| Clayton | Burt | 2016 | New Canaan | Syracuse | ACC | I |
| Mark | Urso | 2016 | Newtown | Cleveland State | ASUN | I |
| Connor | Chamberlin | 2016 | Staples | Monmouth | CAA | I |
| Jack | Healy | 2016 | Taft | Colorado College | HCAC | III |
| Will | Simpson | 2016 | Darien | Colorado College | HCAC | III |
| David | Strupp | 2016 | New Canaan | Harvard | Ivy | I |
| James | Campbell | 2016 | Brien McMahon | UPENN | Ivy | I |
| Jack | O'Connor | 2016 | Fairfield Prep | Bowdoin | NESCAC | III |
| Jake | Kirby | 2016 | Darien / Westminster (PG) | Colby | NESCAC | III |
| Brendan | Seiler | 2016 | Darien | Colby | NESCAC | III |
| Brendan | Hoffman | 2016 | Fairfield Prep | Williams | NESCAC | III |
| Connor | Waldron | 2016 | Berkshire | Holy Cross | Patriot | I |
| Peter | Swindell | 2016 | New Canaan | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| Frank | Cognetta | 2015 | New Canaan | Richmond | A10 | I |
| Michael | Kraus | 2015 | New Canaan / Taft (PG) | Virginia | ACC | I |
| Max | Begoon | 2015 | New Canaan | Denver | Big East | I |
| Justin | Meichner | 2015 | New Canaan / Taft (PG) | Georgetown | Big East | I |
| Spencer | Turkel | 2015 | Weston | Delaware | CAA | I |
| Cam | Harris | 2015 | Fairfield Prep | Drexel | CAA | I |
| Owen | Toland | 2015 | New Canaan | Franklin & Marshall | Centennial | III |
| Brandon | Salvatore | 2015 | Taft | Cornell | Ivy | I |
| Logan | Hart | 2015 | New Canaan | Skidmore | Liberty | III |
| Liam | Harris | 2015 | New Canaan | Union | Liberty | III |
| Ryan | Seymour | 2015 | Westminster | Denison | NCAC | III |
| Sterling | O’Hara | 2015 | New Canaan | Ohio Wesleyan | NCAC | III |
| Ted | Dumbauld | 2015 | New Canaan | Bucknell | Patriot | I |
| Lucas | Jackson | 2015 | Staples | Loyola | Patriot | I |
| | | | | | |
